Let electorate, not courts, decide election winners, Adefope-Okojie tells judiciary


Politics

By Anthony Isibor

THE retired Justice of the Court of Appeal, Oludotun Adefope-Okojie, says that the electorate, rather than the courts, must have the final say in determining who governs, warning against judicial decisions that replace the choices made by voters at the polls.

She said although the judiciary had a constitutional responsibility to adjudicate electoral disputes, its intervention would lose legitimacy when it displaced the democratic choices of the electorate.

Adefope-Okojie stated this on Tuesday while delivering the guest lecture at the 2026 Gavel International Annual Conference and Awards in Lagos.

Speaking on the theme, “Electoral Process in Nigeria: Managing the Boundaries of Judicial Intervention”, she argued that the courts should recognise that their responsibility was to protect the people’s mandate, not assume the role of the electorate.

She said Nigeria’s democracy rested on two fundamental promises: that the people must be allowed to choose their representatives and that every election must be conducted in accordance with the law.

According to her, the two principles should complement each other, but problems arise when judicial intervention is allowed to override the choices expressed through the ballot.

“When the courts enforce the law faithfully, the two promises reinforce each other. But when they are drawn into deciding who governs the world or not from the vote, the second promise begins to consume the first,” she said.

The retired justice expressed concern that elections in Nigeria have increasingly become contests decided in courtrooms rather than at polling units.

She said that candidates now prepare for election tribunals almost as carefully as they prepare for campaigns, while the expression “go to court” has become an accepted response to electoral defeat.

She maintained that the growing involvement of the judiciary in electoral outcomes should not be interpreted as a reason to deny aggrieved parties access to justice.

Rather, she said, courts should ensure that their decisions strengthen the democratic process and preserve the sovereignty of the electorate.

Adefope-Okojie identified five components of Nigerians’ constitutional right to choose their representatives: access to voting, the freedom to choose among lawfully nominated candidates, equality of votes, effectiveness in ensuring that declared results reflect votes cast, and access to independent judicial remedies.

She, however, stressed that the right to seek judicial redress existed to protect the other four components and should not be used to defeat them.

“A remedy that defeats access, choice, equality, or effectiveness is a remedy against the right it was meant to secure,” she said.

She questioned the tendency to treat election disputes largely as disagreements between political parties and candidates, while overlooking the interests of the electorate whose votes ultimately determine political mandates.

According to her, voters are the absent party in many election petitions because the legal framework largely gives candidates and political parties the right to challenge election outcomes.

She cited the Zamfara State dispute, in which the Supreme Court nullified the All Progressives Congress primaries over the party’s failure to conduct valid primaries, resulting in votes cast for its candidates being treated as wasted.

The decision led to candidates of the Peoples Democratic Party emerging as winners across several elective positions in the state, despite the APC having secured the overwhelming majority of votes.

She also referred to the Bayelsa governorship dispute, in which the Supreme Court disqualified the deputy governorship candidate of the APC over false information submitted to INEC, resulting in the disqualification of the joint ticket and the emergence of the PDP candidate.

Adefope-Okojie said such cases demonstrated the need for judicial decisions to take proper account of the rights and interests of voters.

She also criticised the use of legal technicalities to overturn electoral outcomes, arguing that procedural requirements should not become instruments for frustrating the people’s choices.

She said courts must avoid situations in which candidates who secured the majority of votes lose their mandates because of technical interpretations of electoral laws.

The retired justice urged the judiciary to interpret electoral legislation in a manner that promotes justice and makes it possible for genuine allegations of electoral malpractice to be established.

She maintained that judicial intervention was necessary to preserve constitutional government, enforce electoral laws and protect citizens’ political rights, but insisted that it must remain within limits that respect the electorate’s authority.

According to her, the ultimate test of electoral justice should be whether the judicial process protects the votes cast by Nigerians and ensures that the people they choose are allowed to govern.

Adefope-Okojie said this balance was particularly important ahead of the 2027 general elections, when the judiciary would again face significant electoral disputes and public scrutiny.

A.I

Nov. 17, 2026

Tags: Gavel INEC Oludotun Adefope-Okojie