Judiciary
By Anthony Isibor
A Senior Advocate of Nigeria (SAN), Anthony George-Ikoli, has cautioned against judicial overreach in Nigeria’s electoral process, saying that the courts must protect electoral integrity without substituting their decisions for the democratic choices of voters.
Delivering the opening remarks as chairman of the 2026 Gavel International Annual Conference and Awards on Tuesday in Lagos, George-Ikoli said that the judiciary should strike a balance between its constitutional responsibility to safeguard electoral legality and the need to respect the sovereign will of the electorate.
Speaking on the theme, “Electoral Process in Nigeria: Managing the Boundaries of Judicial Intervention”, he described it as both timely and timeless, noting that it addressed one of the most delicate questions in constitutional democracy: the relationship between the ballot and the bench.
According to him, while the ballot box expresses the will of the people, the courtroom exists to safeguard the legality of the electoral process.
He warned that neither institution should usurp the constitutional responsibilities of the other.
“The judiciary must neither become an alternative electoral commission nor abdicate its responsibility as the ultimate guardian of electoral legality. That is the delicate boundary we are here this morning to interrogate,” he said.
Ikoli identified dangers in both excessive and inadequate judicial intervention, explaining that an overreaching judiciary could inadvertently substitute its judgment for the democratic choices of voters, while a judiciary that fails to act could allow electoral illegality to go without an effective remedy.
He stressed that judicial restraint should not amount to judicial retreat, just as judicial courage should not degenerate into overreach.
“The challenge, therefore, is not whether the courts should intervene in electoral matters. Of course, they must, where the law and the facts justify intervention. The more difficult question is how far, on what grounds and within what constitutional limits,” he said.
He argued that the objective of electoral adjudication should go beyond declaring winners to ensuring that the process through which political leaders emerge commands public confidence.
He maintained that an election should not be considered credible simply because a winner has been declared, but because the process that produced the winner can withstand legal scrutiny.
“An election is not credible merely because a winner has emerged. It is credible when the process that produced the winner can withstand the scrutiny of the law,” he said.
Ikoli also cautioned against treating the judiciary as a substitute for responsible electoral administration, noting that courts could not resolve every institutional weakness in Nigeria’s electoral system through their judgments.
He said the country should work towards an electoral system in which fewer disputes require judicial intervention and those that reach the courts are resolved in accordance with the law, constitutional principles and the demands of justice.
He further challenged stakeholders to consider how the judiciary could remain sufficiently strong to protect democracy while exercising restraint within its constitutional boundaries.
According to him, the question is not one for judges and lawyers alone, but for every citizen concerned about ensuring that political power derives its legitimacy from the Constitution and the freely expressed will of the people.
Ikoli said that the conference was an opportunity to deepen discussions on electoral justice and constitutional governance, expressing confidence that the guest lecturer’s professional experience and scholarship would enrich the debate.
A.I
Nov. 17, 2026
Tags: Anthony George-Ikoli Gavel International Annual Conference and Awards
